Enchanted by the Power of the Evil Eye ~The Harem School Life Crafted by a Girl Falling Under My Hypnosis~ - Chapter 37: Natsumi’s Confession…

Chapter 37: Natsumi’s Confession…

“NOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!”

Natsumi screamed, her most guarded secret exposed to me, continuing to cry out.

Unable to move her body, she screamed like a madwoman while forced to keep smiling as per my command…

Meanwhile, Yukino kept stimulating her with a vibrator, preparing her for what’s next… Well, Natsumi seems too overwhelmed to care…

“Natsumi, be quiet.”

I decided to silence her for now; she was too loud to continue talking.

“Huh, ha, ah… guhaa, gohoo, ga, gaboo, gehoo.”

Forced to calm down, Natsumi choked, unable to keep up with her body’s changes.

“Oh, poor thing.”

Yukino rubbed Natsumi’s back with the hand not holding the vibrator.

“Haa, haa, haa… M-Mamoru… It’s not… It’s not like that…”

Natsumi looked at me with pleading eyes.

“Natsumi, you can stop smiling.”

It was getting hard to talk with that forced smile.

“Ah, ha, ah…”

Natsumi’s smile faded, her cute face crumpling in distress.

“Honestly, I’m shocked… You liked another guy, huh?”

I made the saddest face I could. I’m genuinely shocked, though…

“No, it’s not, it’s not like that, it’s not…”

I stared at Natsumi silently, with the coldest eyes I could muster.

“Come on, tell Mamo-kun how you did it. If you’re honest, he might forgive you. Fufu.”

Yukino gently stroked Natsumi’s head.

“Eh, egu, egu… A college senpai from taekwondo… Just once… He came to teach us… After practice… He lived alone in an apartment… We all went to hang out…”

Natsumi chose her words carefully, glancing at my face.

“Before I knew it… everyone else left… It was just the two of us, and the mood changed… and then…”

“…”

I listened silently. I’d heard this from Natsumi once before, but…

“I was growing distant from Mamoru… and I thought… maybe it didn’t matter… and it just happened…”

Natsumi looked away from me.

“So, you’re saying it’s my fault?”

“Huh, no, that’s not, it’s not…”

Natsumi hurriedly looked back at me.

“Saying you liked me was a lie, huh… Slut.”

I glared at her and spat the word out.

“Ah… No, it’s not…”

Natsumi went blank, unable to speak. She might be truly broken this time…

“Are you dating that guy now? You like him, right? Not Mamo-kun?”

Yukino teased, stroking Natsumi’s head soothingly.

“No… I haven’t seen him since… I don’t like him… I… I like Mamoru…”

Natsumi looked at me with desperate, pleading eyes.

“You like Mamo-kun? Even after doing it with someone else? I think Mamo-kun would hate a girl like that.”

Yukino stopped stroking her head and moved the vibrator back and forth.

“Look, no hymen, so it slides in and out easily! You comforted yourself like this every night, right? Imagining Mamo-kun while giving your virginity to someone else… How does that feel? Were you comparing them in your fantasies?”

Yukino’s teasing grin twisted into one of amusement.

Natsumi lay passive, unresisting as Yukino stirred her with the vibrator, the only sound being the wet noises it made.

Gucho, gucho… gucha…

Unable to even speak, Natsumi’s mouth twitched slightly.

“That’s cruel… so cruel… Why… Why are you doing this… I loved you… I loved you… Onee-chan… Onee-chan…”

Natsumi sobbed uncontrollably… She’s so cute…

“I loved Mamoru so much… I really loved him… Always, always… I love him… I still love him…”

She looked at me, her face a mess of tears and snot.

I’m sorry, Natsumi… I know you love me.

But you hate dishonesty, and if you blabbed about what I’m doing “for my sake” or tried to stop me, it’d be a hassle.

I was going to seal your lips and teach you how to act for my benefit…

But if you did it with another guy, that changes things. I believed you weren’t that kind of girl… I feel betrayed…

You weren’t like that before, but you’ve changed…

So, I have to make sure you never betray me again…

It’s your fault, Natsumi… This is necessary for you too…

Don’t worry… When it’s all over, you’ll be the old Natsumi again…

My cute Natsumi… I’ll make you that way again…

Alright, it’s about time. Breaking her further would be a waste.

I stood and approached Natsumi.

I moved slowly, deliberately, and then…

“I… loved you too, Natsumi…”

I gently hugged her, feeling her body heat, heightened from Yukino’s teasing.

“Huh…?”

Natsumi looked confused, not understanding.

“I loved you too, but after I got this scar, I think I started avoiding you… That was my fault, right?”

I showed her the scar on my forehead, a wedge in her heart… Thanks to Yukino for the info. She’s so useful…

“No, that’s not true… I’m the one who hurt you… I’m sorry, so sorry…”

“Natsumi, look into my eyes…”

I peered into her eyes… Her heart was already shattered. All I had to do was reshape it.

“Ah… n… ah…”

The light in Natsumi’s eyes faded, becoming vacant. Her body went limp, fully leaning on Yukino.

Yukino lovingly stroked her cute little sister’s head.

“Natsumi, you’ll answer all my questions honestly. Got it?”

“…Y-Yeah, I’ll answer everything honestly…”

“Your response is ‘Yes.’”

“…Yes…”

Gotta establish the master-servant dynamic properly.

Natsumi’s heart now absorbs my words without resistance.

“Natsumi, your body is free to move now…”

Judging she wouldn’t resist anymore, I restored her freedom.

“Natsumi, what did you think of the guy you first had sex with?”

Natsumi didn’t answer immediately, her mouth twitching slightly before she spoke.

“I thought… he was kinda okay…”

Well, you let him sleep with you, so I’m relieved you’re not the type to do it with someone you don’t care about.

“Compared to me?”

“I love Mamoru more… But… we were growing distant… and I thought you liked Onee-chan, so I figured… maybe it’s fine… to just go with it…”

I see… Guess I’ll take the blame… Gotta take responsibility, then…

“Natsumi, my Natsumi… Listen closely…”

I whispered into Natsumi’s ear.

“N, nn, y-yes… I’m listening…”

Natsumi fidgeted as my breath tickled her ear, responding softly.

“Knowing you were held by another guy… It doesn’t feel good… I might really start to hate you…”

“No, no, please, don’t… I’m sorry, forgive me, please forgive me… Don’t hate me…”

Natsumi started crying again, her face crumpling… The tears streaming from her lifeless eyes are so striking…

Her crying face is thrilling to watch… I could look at it forever… But,

“That’s why I want to overwrite what that guy left on your body… With me… Once you become mine, Natsumi… I’ll love you again, keep you by my side forever…”

“H-how… do I do that…?”

Natsumi looked at me with vacant eyes. I don’t know if I’m reflected in them, but…

“Tell me everything you did with that guy.”

“Huh? E-everything… I have to say it…?”

“Yes, you’ll tell me with your own mouth. I’ll do the same things and overwrite it all. Then, you can become mine, right? So, cooperate, okay?”

Natsumi’s vacant eyes widened, her mouth trembling, but…

“O-okay… I’ll let Mamoru overwrite it… I’ll become Mamoru’s… I’ll cooperate…”

Everything’s set now. Natsumi will willingly help to become mine.

“When I clap my hands, you’ll return to your senses. And we’ll work on overwriting together, as I said. Got it?”

“Hai… I’ll return to my senses… and work on overwriting… together…”

Clap!

I clapped my hands in front of Natsumi’s face, and she flinched. After a moment of daze, she blinked.

Her eyes, blinking a few times, regained their light. She’s back to her senses.

“Now, Natsumi, tell me about the day you lost your virginity.”

“Ah, uh, that day…”

Natsumi hesitated but slowly began to speak…